Systematic review of the biological variation data for diabetes related analytes
Por:
Gonzalez-Lao, E, Corte, Z, Simon, M, Ricos, C, Coskun, A, Braga, F, Aarsand, AK, Carobene, A, Bartlett, WA, Boned, B, Asland, B, Diaz-Garzon, J, Marques-Garcia, F, Minchinela, J, Perich, C, Fernandez-Calle, P, Roraas, T, Fernandez-Fernandez, P, Jonker, N and Sandberg, S
Publicada:
1 ene 2019
Ahead of Print:
31 oct 2018
Resumen:
Background: Objective interpretation of laboratory test results used to diagnose and monitor diabetes mellitus in part requires the application of biological variation data (BVD). The quality of published BVD has been questioned. The aim of this study was to quality assess publications reporting BVD for diabetes-related analytes using the Biological Variation Data Critical Appraisal Checklist (BIVAC); to assess whether published BVD are fit for purpose and whether the study design and population attributes influence BVD estimates and to undertake a meta-analysis of the BVD from BIVAC-assessed publications.
Methods: Publications reporting data for glucose, HbA(1c), adiponectin, C-peptide, fructosamine, insulin like growth factor 1 (IGF-1), insulin like growth factor binding protein 3 (IGFBP-3), insulin, lactate and pyruvate were identified using a systematic literature search. These publications were assessed using the BIVAC, receiving grades A, B, C or D, where A is of highest quality. A meta-analysis of the BVD from the assessed studies utilised weightings based upon BIVAC grades and the width of the data confidence intervals to generate global BVD estimates.
Results: BIVAC assessment of 47 publications delivered 1 A, 3 B, 39C and 4 D gradings. Publications relating to adiponectin, C-peptide, IGF-1, IGFBP-3, lactate and pyruvate were all assessed as grade C. Meta-analysis enabled global BV estimates for all analytes except pyruvate, lactate and fructosamine.
Conclusions: This study delivers updated and evidence-based BV estimates for diabetes-related analytes. There remains a need for delivery of new high-quality BV studies for several clinically important analytes.
Filiaciones:
Gonzalez-Lao, E:
Spanish Soc Lab Med SEQCML, Analyt Qual Commiss, Barcelona, Spain
Qual Healthcare, Grp ACMS, Madrid, Spain
Corte, Z:
Spanish Soc Lab Med SEQCML, Analyt Qual Commiss, Barcelona, Spain
San Agustin Univ Hosp, Aviles, Asturias, Spain
Simon, M:
Spanish Soc Lab Med SEQCML, Analyt Qual Commiss, Barcelona, Spain
Intercomarcal Lab Consortiums Alt Penedes Anoia &, Barcelona, Spain
Ricos, C:
Spanish Soc Lab Med SEQCML, Analyt Qual Commiss, Barcelona, Spain
Coskun, A:
Acibadem Univ, Sch Med, Istanbul, Turkey
Braga, F:
Univ Milan, Res Ctr Metrol Traceabil Lab Med CIRME, Milan, Italy
Aarsand, AK:
Haukeland Hosp, Norwegian Porphyria Ctr, Lab Clin Biochem, Bergen, Norway
Haraldsplass Deaconess Hosp, Norwegian Qual Improvement Lab Examinat NOKLUS, Bergen, Norway
Carobene, A:
Osped San Raffaele, Serv Med Lab, Milan, Italy
Bartlett, WA:
Ninewells Hosp & Med Sch, Blood Sci, Dundee, Scotland
Boned, B:
Spanish Soc Lab Med SEQCML, Analyt Qual Commiss, Barcelona, Spain
Royo Villanova Hosp, Zaragoza, Spain
Asland, B:
Ctr Proficiency Testing, Inst Qual Management Healthcare, Toronto, ON, Canada
Diaz-Garzon, J:
Spanish Soc Lab Med SEQCML, Analyt Qual Commiss, Barcelona, Spain
La Paz Univ Hosp, Madrid, Spain
Marques-Garcia, F:
Spanish Soc Lab Med SEQCML, Analyt Qual Commiss, Barcelona, Spain
Univ Hosp Salamanca, Dept Clin Biochem, Salamanca, Spain
:
Spanish Soc Lab Med SEQCML, Analyt Qual Commiss, Barcelona, Spain
Germans Trias & Pujol Univ Hosp, Metropolitana Nord Unified Lab LUMN, Badalona, Spain
Perich, C:
Spanish Soc Lab Med SEQCML, Analyt Qual Commiss, Barcelona, Spain
Lab Hosp Vall Hebron, Barcelona, Spain
Fernandez-Calle, P:
Spanish Soc Lab Med SEQCML, Analyt Qual Commiss, Barcelona, Spain
La Paz Univ Hosp, Madrid, Spain
Roraas, T:
Haraldsplass Deaconess Hosp, Norwegian Qual Improvement Lab Examinat NOKLUS, Bergen, Norway
Fernandez-Fernandez, P:
Spanish Soc Lab Med SEQCML, Analyt Qual Commiss, Barcelona, Spain
Jonker, N:
Wilhelmina Ziekenhuis Assen, Certe, Assen, Netherlands
Sandberg, S:
Haukeland Hosp, Norwegian Porphyria Ctr, Lab Clin Biochem, Bergen, Norway
Haraldsplass Deaconess Hosp, Norwegian Qual Improvement Lab Examinat NOKLUS, Bergen, Norway
Univ Bergen, Fac Med & Dent, Dept Global Hlth & Primary Care, Bergen, Norway
|