Genomic newborn screening. Perspective from the Ethics commission of the Spanish Society for Human Genetics. Part I. Next generation sequencing technologies applied to newborn screening. Challenges and opportunities
Por:
Ros, TP, Aytes, AP, Sagredo, JMG, de Bustamante, AD and Guillermo, IB
Publicada:
4 feb 2022
Resumen:
In 2003 at the ending of the Human Genome Project, it aroused the idea that all newborns could be sequenced and its genome archived in the clinical record, in order to manage risks of diseases and response to medicaments along his whole life. Eighteen years later, promises of genomic medicine and tremendous decrease of costs of next generation sequencing technologies, continues feeding this dream that shows important practical, ethical and social challenges and genomic sequencing is presented as the next historical change in newborn screening programs. In this article we analyze challenges and opportunities of next generation sequencing technologies, their real costs, problems associated to management, storage and protection of the enormous amount of genomic data produced and finally, according to conclusions of recent researches, there are considered the conclusions in two contexts, sick newborn with diagnostic purposes and healthy asymptomatic newborns with public health purposes (newborn screening programs). In a second part of this article it will be considered ethical, legal and social issues (ELSI). Final objective is to contribute to scientific, professional, ethics and social debate in order to promote that genome sequencing in newborn don't be used indiscriminately constituting a risk, but properly done, as a partner in the promotion of health and prevention of consequences of genetic diseases.
Filiaciones:
Ros, TP:
Hosp Clin Barcelona, Secc Errores Congenitos Metab IBC, Serv Bioquim & Genet Mol, Barcelona, Spain
Comis Etica Asociac Espanola Genet Humana AEGH, Valencia, Spain
Aytes, AP:
Hosp La Fe, Grp Invest Perinatol, Inst Invest Sanitaria, Valencia, Spain
Comis Etica Asociac Espanola Genet Humana AEGH, Valencia, Spain
Sagredo, JMG:
Univ Alcala, Fac Med, Alcala De Henares, Madrid, Spain
Comis Etica Asociac Espanola Genet Humana AEGH, Valencia, Spain
de Bustamante, AD:
Hosp Univ Mostoles, Unidad Genet, Mostoles, Madrid, Spain
Comis Etica Asociac Espanola Genet Humana AEGH, Valencia, Spain
:
Hosp Univ Germans Trias I Pujol, Badalona, Barcelona, Spain
Comis Etica Asociac Espanola Genet Humana AEGH, Valencia, Spain
Green Accepted, Bronze
|